Can the bombing of dresden be justified

Was the bombing of dresden justified essay understanding the bombing of dresden – cliffsnotes began february 13, 1945, and lasted through april 17 a. President obama’s recent visit to the japanese city of hiroshima is an opportunity to reflect on the moral ramifications of one of the most horrific acts of war in history. Was the bombing of german cities, ie dresden, during world war ii justified, if not why and should the us and uk apologise should the allies have been charged with war crimes for firebombing the innocent civilians of dresden. The worse incident of bombing of civilian population in a war is the bombing by usa of hiroshima and nagasaki in japan perhaps this incident will always remain a blot on history of humanity.

Yes the facts about dresden are stark and ugly this was one of germany's cultural capitals, a city renowned for its elegant architecture and regal atmosphere, yet in february 1945 the allies dropped almost 4,000 tonnes of explosives, laying waste to the iconic cityscape and. Debate: the bombing of civilians one of the main arguments against area bombing and the bombing of dresden is that fact that, in the process of bombing entire cities, civilians are killed those who endorse area bombing and the bombing of dresden argue to justify these deaths. Can the bombing of dresden be justified dresden was germanys 7th largest city at the time of the war historically, dresden had been northern germany’s cultural centre – a city filled with museums and historic buildings. Yes we were justified and in 1999 the dresden city council said so at the time of the bombing 50,000 troops were getting on trains heading for the ussr armouror 3 months ago.

The bombing of dresden was a military bombing by the british royal air force (raf) and the united states army air force (usaaf) as part of the allied forces between 13 february and 15 february 1945 in the second world war. All the same, i do think that the information elsewhere in the article (eg the was the dresden bombing justified section, external links section, etc) are adequate to keep the sentence as it was, without linking sources for it from the opening paragraph. Was the bombing of dresden justified in february 1945, the last year of world war 2, britain sent 300 lancaster bombers to attack the crowded german city of dresden this attack was not the precision bombing of specific military targets. Was the bombing of dresden necessary update cancel ad by scalyr and incidentally to show the russians when they arrive what bomber command can do the bombing of dresden neither was the previous “area bombing raid on hamburg (1943) justified, nor later attacks such as that on tokyo, nor the use of nuclear weapons against.

Dresden was not justified from a military standpoint while there may be some merit to black's claim about churchill's desire to impress the soviets, bomber command was harris' baby, and the pm had very little say in the targeting. (10) john black, the truth about the 1945 bombing of dresden (23rd february 1995) dresden was a center of cultural and architectural wonders, including the famous zwinger museum and palace and the cathedral, the frauenkirche. The bombing of dresden was a british / american aerial bombing attack on the city of dresden , the capital of the german state of saxony , that took place during the. The bombing of dresden, resulting in a fire-storm as it did, was as destructive as if the city had been hit with a nuke of the time all it did was make the people there see the allied powers as cruel and uncaring.

Can the bombing of dresden be justified

The bombing of dresden began february 13, 1945, and lasted through april 17 — a period of two months — yet even today, it remains one of the most controversial military decisions in modern warfare. The bombing of dresden was an attack on the city of dresden, the capital of the german state of saxony, that took place in the final months of the second world war in the european theatre in four raids between 13 and 15 february 1945, 722 heavy bombers. The bombing of dresden in world war ii by the allies remains controversial after more than 50 years dresden, the capital of the german state of saxony, was fire-bombed by allied air forces (the british royal air force (raf) and the united states army air force (usaaf) over three days (february 13-15, 1945) near the end of world war ii.

Dresden bombing essays it was about nine pm on february 13, 1945 eight hundred and five british planes dropped twenty six hundred tons of bombs on dresden soon the city was an inferno the next morning six hundred american planes bombed the city again, and again on the fifteenth of february. Was the allied fire bombing of dresden a war crime or can it be justified as a necessary part of the war effort the suffering of the civilians caught in the firestorm was comparable to many other horrors inflicted during the war by any side. The bombing of dresden, resulting in a fire-storm as it did, was as destructive as if the city had been hit with a nuke of the time all it did was make the people there.

From 13 to 15 february 1945, british (and some american) heavy bombers dropped 2,400 tons of high explosives and 1,500 tons of incendiary bombs onto the ancient cathedral city of dresden. Bombing of dresden in world war ii from wikipedia , the free encyclopedia the bombing of dresden led by the british royal air force (raf) and involving the united states army air forces (usaaf) between february 13 and february 15 , 1945 remains one of the more controversial allied actions of world war ii. The bombing of dresden is sometimes given as an example of modern ‘total war’, meaning that the normal rules of war were not followed targets in total war are not only military, but civilian and the types of weapons used are not restricted. Arguments surrounding the dresden bombings are focused upon three characteristics of the attack these include, the legitimacy of dresden as a justified military target, the disproportionate exercise of violence, and the indiscriminate manner in which violence was exerted.

can the bombing of dresden be justified Wartime ethics: the bombing of dresden updated on january 26, 2018 ata1515 more ata1515 is a student of history, focusing on the modern, medieval, and ancient histories of europe  with the city destroyed the war was won and victory justified any amount of destruction to the enemy. can the bombing of dresden be justified Wartime ethics: the bombing of dresden updated on january 26, 2018 ata1515 more ata1515 is a student of history, focusing on the modern, medieval, and ancient histories of europe  with the city destroyed the war was won and victory justified any amount of destruction to the enemy. can the bombing of dresden be justified Wartime ethics: the bombing of dresden updated on january 26, 2018 ata1515 more ata1515 is a student of history, focusing on the modern, medieval, and ancient histories of europe  with the city destroyed the war was won and victory justified any amount of destruction to the enemy.
Can the bombing of dresden be justified
Rated 3/5 based on 46 review

2018.